Umatilla FL Homes for Sale

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Magnolia Pointe Ph 1 SubDv. ⋅ 32784 Zip Code

Short Sale. **3rd Party Approval Req** This practically new Cali floorplan in Magnolia Pointe, Umatilla, FL 32784 delivers modern comfort with 1,882 sq ft of well-designed living space. This 4-bedroom, 2-bath home features ceramic tile flooring in the main living areas and carpeted bedrooms for added comfort. The open-concept layout connects the living room, dining area, and kitchen—ideal for everyday living and entertaining—while large windows provide great natural light. The kitchen includes quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, a walk-in pantry, and an oversized island with breakfast bar. The private primary suite is located toward the rear and features an ensuite with dual sinks, a separate shower, and a walk-in closet. A dedicated laundry area is conveniently located near all bedrooms. Enjoy family-friendly community amenities including a community pool, playground, sports areas, and walking paths—perfect for evening strolls and a relaxing walk around the community lake. Schedule your private showing today!

955 Bear Hammock Drive, Umatilla

$458,543

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Seasons At Magnolia Pointe SubDv. ⋅ 32784 Zip Code

Welcome to this exciting Ammolite home, ready for quick move-in! Included features: a covered entry; a well-appointed kitchen boasting 42" white cabinets, quartz countertops, a center island, a roomy pantry, and an adjacent dining nook; an elegant great room; a guest suite featuring a living room, bedroom, and full bath; a main-floor powder room; an airy loft; a stunning primary suite showcasing an immense walk-in closet and a private bath; three secondary bedrooms; a shared hall bath; an upstairs laundry; and a relaxing covered patio with center-meet sliding glass doors. This home also offers tile flooring in select rooms. Tour today! *Special financing rates and closing cost assistance may be available. Options may vary by community and offers are available on select homes only. Contact builder for more information!

179 Flag Lilly Lane, Umatilla

$374,999

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Seasons At Magnolia Pointe SubDv. ⋅ 32784 Zip Code

Explore this dynamic Laurel home, ready for quick move-in. Included features: a welcoming covered porch, a thoughtfully designed kitchen offering a walk-in pantry and a center island, a spacious great room, an open dining area, a stunning primary suite showcasing a generous walk-in closet, and a private bath with double sinks, a convenient laundry, a patio, and a 2-car garage. This home also offers additional windows in select rooms. Tour today! 1x capital contribution fee of $850. *Special financing rates and closing cost assistance may be available. Options may vary by community and offers are available on select homes only. Contact builder for more information!

199 Bull Frog Lane, Umatilla

Start Your Search

Prev
1
2
of 2
Next

Umatilla FL Homes for Sale

There are 55 homes for sale in Umatilla, Florida as of 2026-09-19, at a median list price of $352,990 and a median of 57 days on market. Every active Umatilla listing is above, newest first. What follows is what those listings add up to.

Umatilla market at a glance

Active listings	55
Median list price	$352,990
Median price per square foot	$233
Median size	1,563 square feet
Median year built	2005
Median days on market	57
On market 60+ days	26 (47.27%)
Priced below original asking	31 (56.36%)

Source: Stellar MLS via the Bridge RESO feed, pulled 2026-09-19. Updated weekly.

What the numbers say for Umatilla buyers

31 of the 55 Umatilla homes on the market (56%) are asking less than they did on day one, and 26 (47%) have been listed 60 days or longer. Those two figures are the practical case for making an offer here. A seller 57 days in who has already cut once is a different negotiation than one of the 29 listings still inside its first 60 days.

Across the 31 Umatilla listings that have already come down, the typical reduction is 5.56% off the original asking price. That is the size of a first concession, not a final one.

Umatilla homes by price range

Under $250,000	5	9.1%
$250,000 to $400,000	31	56.4%
$400,000 to $600,000	9	16.4%
$600,000 and up	10	18.2%

Property types in Umatilla

Single Family Residence	53
Mobile Home	1
Farm	1

Neighborhoods and subdivisions in Umatilla

Every Umatilla subdivision with an active listing or its own page here, ranked by inventory. A subdivision showing 0 still appears: this is a live MLS feed and inventory changes daily. The 50 homes in named subdivisions are 91% of the Umatilla market; the rest are on unplatted land or were listed without a subdivision name.

Magnolia Pointe11 active$348,990

Twin Lakes Estates5 active$349,900

East Umatilla3 active$339,000*

Twin Lake Estates3 active$295,000*

Shoreline Ranch3 active$769,000*

Umatilla Mitchenors2 active$675,000*

Silver Beach Heights2 active$505,362*

Lee Acres2 active$499,250*

Umatilla Trowells2 active$122,050*

Smiths1 active$1,800,000*

North Umatilla1 active$384,900*

Acreage & Unrec1 active$495,000*

Lynnwood1 active$462,840*

Anna D Guerrant1 active$559,000*

Givens Sub-trowells1 active$309,000*

Lake Murphy Estates1 active$1,050,000*

Osceola Park1 active$319,000*

Whidbys1 active$284,999*

Lake Mary Estates1 active$274,000*

Umatilla Wingfield1 active$364,900*

Beg 1088 Ft N of Sw Cor1 active$254,900*

Vista Oaks1 active$349,900*

Three Lakes1 active$249,000*

Silver Lake Park1 active$239,900*

Oak Park1 active$250,000*

Umatilla Yanceys1 active$284,800*

Subdivision names come from the MLS as agents entered them. Active count and median list price as of 2026-09-19. * Medians on rows with fewer than 4 listings are indicative only. Open a subdivision for days on market, price per square foot and sales history.

More Umatilla subdivisions

No active listing today. Each page keeps its sales history and refills as inventory changes.

About Umatilla

Umatilla is a city of 3,685 at the 2020 census in northern Lake County, known as the Gateway to the Ocala National Forest.

State Road 19 runs through the center of town, eleven miles south to Tavares and fifty-eight miles north through the forest to Palatka. Orlando is thirty-eight miles southeast and Daytona Beach forty-nine miles northeast.

The city was named after Umatilla, Oregon.

Umatilla zip codes

32784 (55 listings)

Umatilla homes by property type

Umatilla Single Family Homes for Sale

Frequently asked questions

How many homes are for sale in Umatilla, FL?

There were 55 active residential listings in Umatilla as of 2026-09-19, at a median list price of $352,990. That count comes from the Stellar MLS feed and is refreshed weekly.

What is the median home price in Umatilla, FL?

The median list price in Umatilla was $352,990 as of 2026-09-19, or about $233 per square foot. The median home on the market is 1,563 square feet and was built in 2005.

How long do homes take to sell in Umatilla?

Median days on market was 57 as of 2026-09-19. 26 of the 55 listings, 47% of the Umatilla market, have been listed 60 days or longer, and that is where most of the negotiating room sits.

Are Umatilla sellers reducing their prices?

31 Umatilla listings, 56.36% of the market, are now asking less than they did originally, at a median reduction of 5.56%. That is the size of a typical first concession here, and it is usually not the last one.

What neighborhoods are in Umatilla, FL?

26 named subdivisions had at least one active listing in Umatilla as of 2026-09-19, and every one is listed above with its own median price and days on market. Magnolia Pointe led with 11 active listings at a median of $348,990.

What zip codes cover Umatilla, FL?

Umatilla listings sat in 1 zip code as of 2026-09-19: 32784 with 55 active listings.

The Homes In Orlando Team at NextHome Neighborhood Realty covers Orange, Seminole, Lake and Volusia counties. Call or text 407-616-9019 to see any Umatilla listing on this page.