Butler Bay Homes for Sale

7 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ Butler Bay SubDv. ⋅ 34786 Zip Code

Set behind the gates of Windermere Club, this extraordinary lakefront estate presents a rare opportunity to experience refined luxury on the shores of Lake Crescent. Situated on a pristine one-acre homesite, this custom-built residence was thoughtfully crafted in 2015 to blend contemporary sophistication with timeless architectural elegance. Fresh exterior and interior paint enhance the home's striking architectural presence and timeless appeal. Encompassing nearly 9,000 square feet of impeccably designed living space, the home features seven bedrooms, seven full baths and one half bath, offering an exceptional balance of grandeur and comfort. Soaring 12-foot ceilings on the main level, 10-foot ceilings upstairs and elegant eight-foot doors enhance the home's impressive architectural scale. Expansive windows and doors frame breathtaking panoramic lake views, flooding the interiors with natural light and creating a seamless connection between indoor and outdoor living. The dramatic great room showcases polished travertine flooring, designer lighting fixtures and stunning vistas at every turn. Designed to inspire culinary excellence, the gourmet kitchen is appointed with professional-grade appliances, a handcrafted wine display, an oversized granite island and an expansive walk-in pantry. Adjacent gathering spaces include an elegant dining room and a welcoming family room. Outdoor living is equally impressive, featuring a resort-style heated swimming pool with a new pool pump, a fully equipped summer kitchen and expansive entertaining areas overlooking the water. An automated mosquito misting system enhances year-round enjoyment of the outdoor spaces. The residence offers first-floor and second-floor primary suites, four additional en-suite guest bedrooms, a private office, a theater room, a sophisticated bar and spacious balconies that capture spectacular sunrise views across the lake. The luxurious primary bath offers a steam room in the shower, creating a spa-inspired retreat within the comfort of home. Thoughtfully equipped with modern efficiencies, the property includes a 25-kW solar energy system with bidirectional metering, two 80-gallon solar-assisted water heaters, a whole-home water purification system, four HVAC systems, a recently installed septic drain field, an underground propane tank and a three-car garage. A private dock provides direct access to Lake Crescent, completing this exceptional waterfront lifestyle. Spanning approximately 187 acres, spring-fed Lake Crescent offers an exceptional setting for boating, waterskiing, fishing and watersports. Unlike the busier Butler Chain of Lakes, Lake Crescent provides a more intimate waterfront experience, combining recreational freedom with the tranquility and privacy of an exclusive lakefront retreat. Ideally situated within reach of Windermere and Winter Garden's premier shopping, dining and recreational destinations, this remarkable estate embodies the very finest in Central Florida lakefront real estate.

3165 Butler Bay Drive N, Windermere

$2,200,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Butler Bay SubDv. ⋅ 34786 Zip Code

Virtually Staged. LUXURY LAKEFRONT ESTATE | 0.64-ACRE LOT | PRIVATE DOCK | PRIVATE POOL | OUTDOOR SUMMER KITCHEN | 3-CAR GARAGE Experience luxury living at its finest in this stunning contemporary lakefront estate, set on an impressive 0.64-acre lot. Featuring two levels of thoughtfully designed living space, this exceptional residence combines elegant architecture, upscale finishes, and breathtaking panoramic lake views. Upon entering through the beautiful solid wood double doors, you are welcomed by an impressive formal living room and a spacious formal dining area. Large panoramic windows frame the spectacular lake views, bringing natural light into the home and creating a seamless connection with the surrounding landscape. A beautifully appointed private office provides the perfect setting for working from home. The gourmet kitchen is truly a chef's dream, featuring high-quality custom cabinetry, quartz countertops, an oversized island, a spacious pantry, and generous workspace. Designed for both everyday living and entertaining, the kitchen flows effortlessly into the inviting family room, complete with custom built-in shelving and a gas fireplace. The luxurious primary suite is a private retreat, featuring elegant wood flooring, separate walk-in closets, and magnificent views of the pool and lake. The spa-inspired primary bathroom offers a large soaking tub and an expansive walk-in shower with dual showerheads. The lower level features three generously sized bedrooms, including one private en-suite bedroom. The remaining two bedrooms share a beautifully designed Jack-and-Jill bathroom, providing comfort and functionality for family members and guests. Additional interior highlights include a fully equipped laundry room with custom cabinetry and a convenient half bathroom with direct access to the pool area. The three-car side-entry garage features built-in storage cabinets, an electric vehicle charging station, and durable epoxy flooring. Step outside and discover your own private paradise! The covered lanai overlooks the beautiful pool and surrounding lake views, creating the perfect setting for relaxation and entertaining. The fully equipped outdoor summer kitchen features a sink, refrigerator, and built-in grill, making outdoor dining and entertaining effortless. Adding to this exceptional property is a private covered dock, offering a unique opportunity to enjoy the waterfront lifestyle. This remarkable lakefront estate brings together space, privacy, luxury, and spectacular views in one extraordinary property. A rare opportunity to own a truly exceptional home where every detail has been thoughtfully designed to elevate everyday living. SCHEDULE YOUR PRIVATE SHOWING TODAY AND EXPERIENCE THIS EXTRAORDINARY LAKEFRONT LIFESTYLE!

2925 Butler Bay Drive N, Windermere

$713,840

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Butler Bay SubDv. ⋅ 34786 Zip Code

4 bedroom 2 bathroom 2,987 square foot home sitting on a 34,848 square foot lot in the gates of Windermere Club, this lakefront residence has resort-style amenities surrounding the beautiful Lake Crescent. Jump on this great deal before its gone! All buyers are responsible to confirm City, County, Zoning, Tax, and other records to their satisfaction before bidding. No inspection contingencies in contract. Absolutely no repairs before closing. This property is sold As-Is.

2128 Lake Crescent Court, Windermere

$1,725,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Butler Bay SubDv. ⋅ 34786 Zip Code

Take your pick! The seller is offering an interest rate buydown with rates as low as 5.5% on a 7-year ARM for qualified buyers, OR a 2025 Godfrey Sweetwater 18' pontoon boat with a 75 HP Yamaha motor. Whether you prefer mortgage savings or making memories on the water, the choice is yours! Set behind the gates of Windermere Club, this lakefront residence delivers everyday comfort with a resort-style backdrop on beautiful Lake Crescent. Offering 4 bedrooms and 3 baths, the home is designed for easy living and effortless entertaining, with bright, open gathering spaces that keep the water views front and center. At the heart of the home, the kitchen pairs generous prep space with a welcoming bar and an adjacent dining area that comfortably seats six, while a separate formal dining room adds flexibility for holidays and special occasions. The main living area is wrapped in expansive windows, filling the home with natural light and framing tranquil lake scenery throughout the day. Step outside to a covered lanai and screened pool area ideal for quiet mornings, sunset dinners, and everything in between. Take a dip in the saltwater pool, now enhanced with a new pool heater and an Aqua Link pool & spa control system for simple, modern management. The primary suite is a private retreat with captivating lake views and a spa-like bath featuring large windows overlooking a secluded courtyard. Three additional bedrooms provide plenty of space for family, guests, or a home office setup. For true lakefront living, enjoy the newer dock with a covered boat lift, perfect for skiing, cruising, kayaking, or paddle boarding whenever the mood strikes. Upgrades and highlights include double pane windows and sliding glass doors, Shark Coating garage floors, a water purifier, Paradise Grill outdoor kitchen with cover and TV, new pool heater, two brand new AC units, a new water heater, plus additional notable improvements throughout. This is the Windermere waterfront lifestyle, refined, relaxed, and ready to enjoy. Be sure to click on the virtual tour links.

2503 Butler Bay Drive N, Windermere

Start Your Search

Orange County › Windermere › Butler Bay

Butler Bay, Windermere

Butler Bay is a neighborhood in west Windermere, in the 34786 zip code, built mostly in the 1980s. Homes are stucco and block. Most homes fall between about 3,000 and 5,100 square feet under air, the median lot is about 0.80 acres, and a three car garage is standard.

Homes here carry an HOA, billed annually, typically around $2,000. Confirm the figure on a specific parcel before relying on it.

What the homes are

Built Mostly built in the 1980s, with homes from 1953 to 2015.
Construction Stucco and block. Tile roofs on 82% of homes.
Style Contemporary, Custom, Traditional
Size Most homes fall between about 3,000 and 5,100 square feet under air.
Bedrooms Five bedrooms is the most common plan, then four.
Garage A three car garage is standard.
Lot The median lot is about 0.80 acres.
HOA Billed annually, typically around $2,000. Confirm on a specific parcel before relying on it.

Where Butler Bay is

Butler Bay, centered at 28.508141, -81.564337. Drag to explore.

Drive times below are measured on the road network from the center of Butler Bay, not straight-line distance, in free-flowing traffic. Treat them as the floor rather than the school-run average.

Driving to	Time	Miles
Downtown Orlando	28 min	16.0
Walt Disney World	24 min	12.2
Orlando International Airport	33 min	27.5
Universal Orlando	23 min	8.9

Public schools nearby

Windermere Elementary School 6 min, 2.0 mi
Lake Whitney Elementary School 5 min, 1.8 mi
Windermere High School 11 min, 3.7 mi
Thornebrooke Elementary School 9 min, 3.8 mi

Private schools nearby

New Academy Inc 8 min, 3.0 mi
Winter Garden Christian Academy 8 min, 3.6 mi
ESTEEM Academy 7 min, 3.1 mi

Parks and recreation

George Bailey Park 6 min, 2.3 mi
Palmer Park 9 min, 3.1 mi
North Edge Park 9 min, 3.5 mi
Warrior Park 7 min, 3.0 mi

Groceries and errands

Armazém X Winter Garden 8 min, 2.6 mi
Target Grocery 10 min, 3.9 mi
Horizon Foods 8 min, 3.0 mi
ALDI 10 min, 3.8 mi

Useful local links

Nearest is not the same as zoned. The schools above are the closest ones to Butler Bay by distance. School attendance zones are set by the district, change from year to year, and can differ street to street inside one neighborhood. Confirm the assignment for a specific address with Orange County Public Schools before it matters to a decision.

Places and drive times from Google, checked 20 September 2026. Businesses open and close; if something here has changed, tell me and I will correct it.

This page tracks what homes in Butler Bay actually sold for over the last twelve months, how long they took, and what moved the price. It is built from 5 verified closed sales in the Stellar MLS feed, not from public estimates. Every figure is a net-of-concessions number, which is explained at the bottom. Updated November 2026.

Read this one loosely. Fewer than eight homes closed here in the last year, so every median on this page rests on a small sample and can swing on a single sale.

What homes sold for in Butler Bay

$1,450,000Median sale price

$367Median per square foot

19 daysMedian days to contract

5Homes sold in 12 months

Sale prices ran from $1,050,000 to $1,954,881, which is a wide spread and the reason a single neighborhood median is a starting point rather than an answer.

By size

Home size	Sales	Median price	Median $/sq ft	Median days
3,000 sq ft and up	5	$1,450,000	$367	19 days

A price per foot taken from the whole neighborhood should never be applied straight to one house.

Seller concessions

20%Of sales included a seller credit

$44,119Typical credit when there was one

1 of 5Sales carrying a credit

A seller credit covers part of the buyer's closing costs and comes off the seller's proceeds, so the headline sale price overstates what the seller kept. Budget for it if you are selling, and ask for it if you are buying.

How buyers paid

Cash 3 sales60%

Conventional 2 sales40%

Cash was 60% of purchases. A high cash share means a seller has buyers who do not depend on an appraisal, and a buyer using a loan is competing against offers that can close faster.

Questions about a specific home in Butler Bay, or want to know what yours would sell for?
Call or text Brenden Rendo at 407-616-9019 or send a message.

About this data. Source is the Stellar MLS feed for Butler Bay in Windermere, Orange County, covering closed sales from 7 November 2025 through 2 November 2026, refreshed monthly and current as of November 2026. Prices are net of seller concessions, so they reflect what the seller actually received rather than the headline number. Data believed accurate but not guaranteed; listings and closings change daily.