
Photo: DanTD, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Lake Mary sits about 20 miles north of downtown Orlando in Seminole County, wrapped around I-4, and it is one of the few Central Florida names people search before they have ever visited. What makes it hard to read from a headline is that it is two markets sharing one zip code. Seven in ten homes that sold here in the last year were single family houses, at a median of $586,500, the highest of the three Seminole County towns compared below. Almost one in seven was a condo, at a median of $175,000, and Lake Mary sold more condos than Winter Springs and Oviedo combined. The citywide median sits in the gap between those two groups and describes neither of them.
Who Lake Mary Fits, and Who It Doesn't
Strong fit: buyers who want a single family house in Seminole County schools, which is seven of every ten sales here; buyers with $1,000,000 or more who want land, because 35 homes on an acre or more closed at a median of $1,350,000 and went under contract in about two weeks, more acreage sales than Winter Springs or Oviedo; first-time buyers and downsizers under $250,000, since condo communities such as Regency Park, Hidden Village and Notting Hill are the cheapest way into the city; anyone whose work is in the Heathrow or Primera office parks; and frequent flyers, because Orlando Sanford International is about 9 minutes from the center of the city.
Weaker fit: anyone who wants new construction, because very few new homes sold here in a year, most of them large houses in Fontaine, the least new building of the three towns compared below; condo and townhome sellers who need to move quickly, since both took seven to eight weeks to go under contract against about four for a single family house; buyers who want an older house to renovate, since only about one sale in seventeen was built before 1980, a third of the share in Winter Springs; anyone counting on the city name to deliver Lake Mary High, because about half of the homes sold here that list a high school list Seminole High instead; and daily commuters with a fixed downtown Orlando start time who cannot absorb I-4 delays.
Still deciding between towns? We pulled the closed sales around a $575,000 budget and put Lake Mary side by side with its neighbors: what $575,000 actually buys in each. Square footage, bedrooms, year built, and how many came with a pool.
Explore Lake Mary
Where Is Lake Mary, and What Makes It Different?
Lake Mary sits in western Seminole County around I-4 at exits 98 and 101, with Sanford to the north and east and Longwood to the south, and the 32746 zip covers essentially all of it. Two things set it apart from its neighbors. The Heathrow and Primera office parks put a real daytime workforce inside the city, so many residents do not commute south at all; for those who do, the mean commute is 24.6 minutes, and the 26 minute drive to downtown Orlando we measured in August 2026 can become 45 or more with one accident on I-4. And Orlando Sanford International is about 9 minutes away, against about 33 to Orlando International. Lake Mary also has a SunRail station, a real option for a weekday downtown office schedule, though service is thin on evenings and weekends. Colonial TownPark and the Lake Mary Boulevard corridor carry most of the restaurants and errands, and Seminole State College has a Lake Mary campus. Schools are Seminole County's, but check the zone for the exact address: among homes sold here in the last year that listed a high school, Seminole High and Lake Mary High each account for about half.
Lake Mary Housing Market Snapshot (2026)
Over the last twelve months 577 homes sold in Lake Mary at a median of $457,000, down 2.0% against the twelve months before. Per square foot, which strips out any change in the size of what sold, it was about flat. In September 2026, 52 homes closed at a median of $479,500 and the typical one went under contract in 33 days. One month is too small a sample to read a direction from, which is why the twelve-month figure leads here. There are 181 active residential listings as of October 23, 2026, with a median asking price of $489,000, or $246 per square foot.
Is Lake Mary a buyer's or seller's market right now? We answer that from current MLS data, weighing months of supply and how close sellers get to their original asking price against the four counties: Is Lake Mary a buyer's or seller's market?
Almost Everything That Sells in Lake Mary Is Resale
Every price figure quoted for Lake Mary mixes brand new homes with existing ones. Split apart, the last twelve months looked like this.
| What sold | Median, prior 12 months | Median, last 12 months | Change | Sales |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New construction | $540,785 | $1,100,000 | +103.4% | 10 |
| Existing homes (resale) | $460,000 | $453,900 | -1.3% | 567 |
| All sales combined | $466,250 | $457,000 | -2.0% | 577 |
Read the new-construction row carefully. It rests on fewer than 50 sales in at least one of the two years. The median new-construction home sold in Lake Mary went from 2,147 square feet to 3,476, 61.9% larger, while the price per square foot moved +21.7%. That is too few to say whether the change is a price move or a change in which homes sold.
The new construction row rests on fewer than 50 sales in at least one of the two years, so read that change as noise rather than a trend.
Lake Mary barely builds. Fewer than one sale in fifty was new, and most of those were large houses in a single community, Fontaine. If new construction is the goal, Winter Springs and Oviedo each sold more new homes than Lake Mary over the same twelve months, most of them townhomes.
Best Neighborhoods in Lake Mary, FL: Communities to Know
Lake Mary is not one market. Ranked by closed sales over the last year, these are the names that actually trade, and they sort into four groups that barely overlap on price.
- Heathrow and the estate communities, Heathrow, the gated golf community and the most recognized address in the city, closed 31 homes, all but one single family, at a median of $760,000; Magnolia Plantation closed 17 at $1,050,000, Timacuan 17 at $715,000 in about 13 days, and Fontaine, the only new construction of any size, 7 houses of about 3,400 square feet at the top of the price range
- The established single family middle, Greenwood Lakes closed 33 at $400,000, Chase Groves 21 at $365,000 in 18 days, Lakewood at the Crossings 21 at $429,500 and Egrets Landing 11 at $400,000: mostly 1980s and 1990s single family neighborhoods, and where a Lake Mary house still comes in near $400,000
- The townhome communities, Fountain Parke, built around 2013, closed 30 townhomes at $437,400; Grande Oaks at Heathrow, also townhomes, closed 14 at $445,000 but took about 80 days; Lake Mary Landings closed 7 at $340,000
- The condos and the entry level, Regency Park closed 25 at $132,000, Notting Hill 13 at $160,000, Hidden Village 14 at $185,000 and Barclay Place 13 at $265,000, and The Forest, a 55-plus manufactured home community, 13 at $215,000: the reason the bottom of the price range exists, and, with the townhomes, the slowest part of the market, with condos as a group taking more than seven weeks to go under contract
Decide which of these you are buying before you read any citywide figure. A Heathrow house and a Regency Park condo share a zip code and almost nothing else, so the honest comparable for either is the community, not the city.
The 15 communities in Lake Mary where the most homes have sold over the last twelve months, each with its own page:
- Heathrow
- Greenwood Lakes
- Fountain Parke At Lake Mary
- Chase Groves
- Magnolia Plantation
- Timacuan
- Hidden Village Condo
- Grande Oaks At Heathrow
- Egrets Landing
- Hills Of Lake Mary
- Woodbridge Lakes
- Colony Cove
- Fontaine
- Griffin Park
- Lake Mary Landings
Another 73 Lake Mary communities have their own page too. You can also browse every Lake Mary listing in one place.
Lake Mary vs. Winter Springs vs. Oviedo: The Honest Comparison
| Lake Mary | Winter Springs | Oviedo | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median asking price | $489,000 | $399,000 | $477,450 |
| Median $/sq ft | $246 | $243 | $243 |
| Mean commute | 24.6 minutes | 30.4 minutes | 26.9 minutes |
| Median household income | $116,944 | $86,332 | $114,092 |
| Population | 16,724 | 38,448 | 39,990 |
Winter Springs is the value move: lower asking prices and three times Lake Mary's share of pre-1980 homes, at the cost of a longer drive to work. Oviedo is the close match on price and income, and the choice between the two usually comes down to which Seminole County school assignments a family wants and which side of the county the job is on. Lake Mary is the one of the three with the most condos, the most acreage sales and the least new construction.
Schools, Commute, and Day-to-Day Life
Seminole County Public Schools serves the city, and assignment varies by address rather than by city name, so confirm the zoning for the specific property before you buy on a school reputation.
Mean travel time to work is 24.6 minutes, against 30.4 from Winter Springs.
Is Lake Mary, FL Safe?
Lake Mary's reported violent crime rate is 65.7 per 100,000 residents against 280.8 for Florida as a whole, about 77% below the state figure. That is a real difference and it is one of the things buyers here are paying for. The same caveat applies in reverse though: rates are measured against resident population, so a town that few people commute into will tend to look better than a comparable one that they do.
Figures are reported offenses from the FBI Crime Data Explorer for the Lake Mary Police Department (ORI FL0590700), 2023, the most recent year that agency reported in a usable form. Reporting years differ between agencies, so this is compared to the Florida rate for the same year and is not comparable to another town's page.
Cost of Living in Lake Mary, FL
Housing is the line that moves a Central Florida budget. Lake Mary's median asking price is $489,000 against a median household income of $116,944, which puts a home at about 4.18 times household income here. That ratio, rather than the sticker price, is the number worth carrying between towns, and it is why a cheaper town is not automatically a more affordable one.
Florida charges no state income tax, so the property tax line matters more here than it would elsewhere, and a homestead exemption reduces the taxable value of a primary residence. Millage varies by taxing district, so treat any single quoted rate as an estimate until the specific parcel is checked.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Lake Mary, FL a good place to live?
Start with the numbers. Against the 60 places this site tracks across Orange, Seminole, Lake and Volusia counties, with that group's middle last measured on October 9, 2026, the median asking price of $489,000 is higher than most and the mean commute of 24.6 minutes is shorter than most. The median household income here is $116,944, which puts housing at 4.18 times income, a lighter load than in most of those places. On local incomes, that makes buying here easier than in most of the group. Who it fits, and who it does not, is laid out at the top of this page.
What is the median home price in Lake Mary, FL?
The median sale price was $479,500 in September 2026 across 52 closed sales. Over the last twelve months 577 homes sold at a median of $457,000, down 2.0% against the twelve months before. The median asking price across 181 active listings is $489,000, or $246 per square foot.
Is Lake Mary cheaper than Winter Springs?
On the asking median, no: $489,000 against $399,000. Measured against household income, Lake Mary is at 4.18 times income and Winter Springs at 4.62, so on that basis Lake Mary is the more affordable of the two. See what $575,000 buys in each town.
Is Lake Mary, FL safe?
The reported violent crime rate runs about 77% below the Florida average, though city rates are measured against resident population while the offense count includes everyone passing through.
What is the cost of living in Lake Mary, FL?
Housing is the deciding line. A median asking price of $489,000 against a median household income of $116,944 puts a home at roughly 4.18 times income, and Florida charges no state income tax, which shifts weight onto the property tax line.
What school district serves Lake Mary, FL?
Seminole County Public Schools. Assignment varies by address within the city, so confirm the zoning for the specific property.
Thinking About a Move to Lake Mary?
I work these four counties every week and I will tell you when a town is wrong for you. If you want the numbers for your budget before you tour anything, start with what $575,000 buys across Lake Mary and its neighbors, or call me at 407-616-9019.
You can also browse homes for sale in Lake Mary, which updates with current inventory.
