North Triplet Lake from Secret Lake Park in Casselberry, Florida
Photo: Seldom4, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The short answer: For a buyer who wants Seminole County schools close to Orlando for less than Winter Springs, Casselberry is usually a good fit. What you get is an older house, often near a lake, in a city that runs its own parks, water and sewer. The trade is speed and traffic: the good houses go under contract fast, and daily life runs along 17-92 and SR 436 rather than through a downtown.

Casselberry is the entry point to the Seminole County school district for a house buyer who wants to stay close to Orlando. The typical one is a 1,700 square foot house from around 1980, it closes near $400,000, and it is under contract in under three weeks. Almost nothing new is being built, a handful of homes in a year, so what a buyer gets is an older house, often near one of the city's lakes, and usually a fast decision.

$356,750
Median Sale Price
September 2026, 22 closed sales
29,473
Population
U.S. Census ACS 2023, up 5.4% since 2019
116
Active Listings
Active residential listings in the city, October 23, 2026
26.7 min
Mean Commute
Against 30.4 minutes from Winter Springs

Who Casselberry Fits, and Who It Doesn't

Strong fit: first-time and move-up buyers who want Seminole County schools at an entry price, because the 163 homes built before 1980 closed at a median of $325,000 and the 1980s and 1990s tier at $360,000; buyers who can move fast, since the median house went under contract in under three weeks and Carriage Hill and Hollowbrook West sold in about a week; anyone who wants to live on a lake for less, because the 34 waterfront sales closed at about $462,500, a much smaller step up from the typical house than waterfront carries in Winter Springs; and buyers who do not want an association, since about two in five sales here had none, at about the same price as the homes that did.

Weaker fit: buyers who want new construction, because there is effectively none; anyone who wants a larger or newer house, since most of the homes built since 2000 are in Legacy Park, Lost Lake Estates and Oakhurst Reserve, where Legacy Park and Oakhurst Reserve typically close at about $465,000 and Lost Lake Estates at about $475,000, with Legacy Park's Reserve section near $520,000; condo buyers who need a quick resale, because the 45 condos that sold took a median of 61 days to go under contract at about $147,000; and anyone looking for a downtown, because Casselberry is organized around 17-92 and State Road 436 rather than a center.

Still deciding between towns? We pulled the closed sales around a $400,000 budget and put Casselberry side by side with its neighbors: what $400,000 actually buys in each. Square footage, bedrooms, year built, and how many came with a pool.

Where Is Casselberry, and What Makes It Different?

Casselberry sits in south Seminole County between Altamonte Springs and Winter Springs, along 17-92 and State Road 436, with Red Bug Lake Road on its southeast side and lakes scattered through its neighborhoods. Most of it was built between the 1960s and the 1990s and little land has been left since. The mean commute is 26.7 minutes, about the same as Altamonte Springs and shorter than Winter Springs.

Casselberry Housing Market Snapshot (2026)

Over the last twelve months 403 homes sold in Casselberry at a median of $360,000, up 5.1% against the twelve months before. Per square foot, which strips out any change in the size of what sold, it was about flat. In September 2026, 22 homes closed at a median of $356,750 and the typical one went under contract in 7 days. One month is too small a sample to read a direction from, which is why the twelve-month figure leads here. There are 116 active residential listings as of October 23, 2026, with a median asking price of $289,950, or $215 per square foot.

Wondering whether it is a buyer's or seller's market around Casselberry? We publish that answer for Seminole County as a whole, from current MLS data: Is Seminole County a buyer's or seller's market?

Best Neighborhoods in Casselberry, FL: Communities to Know

Casselberry prices by decade, and a handful of communities carry most of the sales.

  • The 1960s and 1970s neighborhoods, where the entry price is: Camelot closed 14 at about $386,000, Carriage Hill 12 at about $373,000 in under a week, Summerset North 10 at about $327,000 and Queens Mirror South 8 at about $300,000
  • Deer Run and Sterling Park, two of the largest communities by sales, both with an association and a mix of houses and townhomes: Deer Run closed 32 at about $332,000 and Sterling Park 27 at about $366,000, each in under four weeks
  • Legacy Park, Lost Lake Estates and Oakhurst Reserve, the homes built since 2000 and the top of the market: Legacy Park closed 19 at about $463,000, townhomes included, with 8 more in its Reserve section at about $520,000, Lost Lake Estates 9 at $475,000 and Oakhurst Reserve 9 at about $465,000 in under three weeks
  • Townhomes and condos, 58 townhomes at about $282,000, with Summerhill at $275,000, and 45 condos at about $147,000, with Summit Village at about $155,000; the townhomes go under contract about a week slower than the houses and the condos take about two months

If the budget is under $375,000, shop the 1960s and 1970s neighborhoods and expect to compete. If it is $460,000 and up, three communities hold most of what was built this century.

The 15 communities in Casselberry where the most homes have sold over the last twelve months, each with its own page:

Another 57 Casselberry communities have their own page too. You can also browse every Casselberry listing in one place.

Casselberry vs. Winter Springs vs. Altamonte Springs: The Honest Comparison

 CasselberryWinter SpringsAltamonte Springs
Median asking price$289,950$399,000$199,900
Median $/sq ft$215$243$177
Mean commute26.7 minutes30.4 minutes26.8 minutes
Median household income$57,816$86,332$64,106
Population29,47338,44845,657

Winter Springs is the neighbor to the north and the step up: a higher household income, Tuscawilla at the top, a median single-family sale of $480,000 and a longer commute. Altamonte Springs is the neighbor to the west, with more than five times the condo sales and a median single-family sale of about $417,000. Casselberry is the one of the three with the lowest price for a single-family house, and its story is simple: mostly houses, mostly older, the typical house under contract in under three weeks. The asking medians in the table mix condos with houses, which is why Altamonte Springs shows a lower number there.

Schools, Commute, and Day-to-Day Life

Seminole County Public Schools serves the city, and assignment varies by address rather than by city name, so confirm the zoning for the specific property before you buy on a school reputation.

Mean travel time to work is 26.7 minutes, against 30.4 from Winter Springs.

Getting around. US 17-92 and SR 436 cross in the middle of Casselberry and carry most of the daily driving. The city's 2024 Vision Zero plan ranks SR 436 first on its list of the roads where people are killed or badly hurt. Two bigger changes are under way or coming: SR 417 is being widened from four to eight lanes between Aloma Avenue and north of SR 434, work the Turnpike expects to run through 2030, and Winter Park Drive gets a shared-use path and signal upgrades, with construction set for 2027. There is no SunRail stop in the city; the nearest stations are Altamonte Springs and Longwood, with Maitland a little farther. (Vision Zero plan, SR 417 widening, city transportation projects, SunRail stations)

Schools by name. Three Seminole County public elementary schools have Casselberry addresses: Casselberry Elementary, Red Bug Elementary and Sterling Park Elementary. South Seminole Middle is on South Winter Park Drive. No district high school has a Casselberry address, so which one a house is zoned for depends on the street. Type the address into the district's School Zone Search before you rely on a school name, because the printed zone maps are older than the lookup tool. (SCPS school listings, SCPS School Zone Search)

Parks and water. The city runs 17 parks on 122 acres. Lake Concord Park, around City Hall, is where the jazz concerts and festivals happen; Secret Lake Park has the recreation center, two fishing piers and the courts; and the 5-mile Greenway Trail links four parks, two schools and local shopping. The parks bond voters passed in 2020 has already rebuilt Wirz Park and opened the new Casselberry Wheel Park. (city parks, Greenway Trail, parks bond projects)

Flood and insurance. The city's own position is that every property here carries some flood risk, and a standard homeowners policy does not cover flood. Casselberry is a Class 7 community in FEMA's Community Rating System, which FEMA lists as a 15 percent discount on NFIP flood policies in the city. Look up the specific address on FEMA's flood map and ask whether the seller has an elevation certificate. Homeowners premiums including wind were roughly flat in Seminole County from September 2025 to March 2026, so the bill comes down to the house: roof age, wind mitigation and elevation. (city flood information, FEMA CRS list, FEMA flood map, our insurance premium analysis)

Water and services. The city itself supplies water and sewer, and sells reclaimed water for irrigation where the lines reach. Where they do not, a separate irrigation meter keeps lawn water off the sewer bill. Garbage, recycling and yard waste are city service through Waste Pro. The city does not name a single electric provider, so confirm it for the address. (city utilities, irrigation rules)

Is Casselberry, FL Safe?

Casselberry's reported violent crime rate is 342.2 per 100,000 residents against 280.8 for Florida as a whole, so it runs above the state figure, and the context matters more than the number. Rates are calculated against resident population while the offense count includes everyone passing through, so a town that draws more workers, shoppers or visitors each day than it has residents will read higher than its residents' own risk.

Figures are reported offenses from the FBI Crime Data Explorer for the Casselberry Police Department (ORI FL0590200), 2023, the most recent year that agency reported in a usable form. Reporting years differ between agencies, so this is compared to the Florida rate for the same year and is not comparable to another town's page.

Cost of Living in Casselberry, FL

Housing is the line that moves a Central Florida budget. Casselberry's median asking price is $289,950 against a median household income of $57,816, which puts a home at about 5.02 times household income here. That ratio, rather than the sticker price, is the number worth carrying between towns, and it is why a cheaper town is not automatically a more affordable one.

Florida charges no state income tax, so the property tax line matters more here than it would elsewhere, and a homestead exemption reduces the taxable value of a primary residence. Millage varies by taxing district, so treat any single quoted rate as an estimate until the specific parcel is checked.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Casselberry, FL a good place to live?

Start with the numbers. Against the 60 places this site tracks across Orange, Seminole, Lake and Volusia counties, with that group's middle last measured on October 9, 2026, the median asking price of $289,950 is lower than most and the mean commute of 26.7 minutes is shorter than most. The median household income here is $57,816, which puts housing at 5.02 times income, a lighter load than in most of those places. On local incomes, that makes buying here easier than in most of the group. Who it fits, and who it does not, is laid out at the top of this page.

What is the median home price in Casselberry, FL?

The median sale price was $356,750 in September 2026 across 22 closed sales. Over the last twelve months 403 homes sold at a median of $360,000, up 5.1% against the twelve months before. The median asking price across 116 active listings is $289,950, or $215 per square foot.

Is Casselberry cheaper than Winter Springs?

On the asking median, yes: $289,950 against $399,000. Measured against household income, Casselberry is at 5.02 times income and Winter Springs at 4.62, so on that basis Winter Springs is the more affordable of the two. See what $400,000 buys in each town.

Is Casselberry, FL safe?

The reported violent crime rate runs above the Florida average, though city rates are measured against resident population while the offense count includes everyone passing through.

What is the cost of living in Casselberry, FL?

Housing is the deciding line. A median asking price of $289,950 against a median household income of $57,816 puts a home at roughly 5.02 times income, and Florida charges no state income tax, which shifts weight onto the property tax line.

What school district serves Casselberry, FL?

Seminole County Public Schools. Assignment varies by address within the city, so confirm the zoning for the specific property.

Is Casselberry considered Orlando?

Not officially. Casselberry is its own city in south Seminole County, between Altamonte Springs and Winter Springs, with its own city government, parks and water utility. It is part of the Orlando metro area: downtown Orlando is to the south, and the city puts Interstate 4 less than 5 miles away.

What is Casselberry, FL known for?

Its lakes and its location. Casselberry sits where US 17-92 and SR 436 cross, between Orlando and the rest of Seminole County, with lakes scattered through its older neighborhoods. Lake Concord Park, around City Hall, is home to the Casselberry Jazz concerts and the Casselberry Art House.

Is there SunRail in Casselberry?

No. The nearest SunRail stations are Altamonte Springs and Longwood, with Maitland a little farther, and LYNX Route 436S runs along SR 436 to the Altamonte Springs station.

Do I need flood insurance in Casselberry?

A federally backed mortgage requires it when the house is in a high-risk flood zone, and a lender can ask for it elsewhere. The city says every property has some flood risk and a standard homeowners policy does not cover flood. NFIP flood policies in the city get FEMA's Class 7 discount, which FEMA lists at 15 percent.

Thinking About a Move to Casselberry?

I work these four counties every week and I will tell you when a town is wrong for you. If you want the numbers for your budget before you tour anything, start with what $400,000 buys across Casselberry and its neighbors, or call me at 407-616-9019.

You can also browse homes for sale in Casselberry, which updates with current inventory.